Steampunk model gets trouble for not being steampunk enough

Embed from Getty Images

Back in July this year, steampunk model Amy Wilder attended the San Diego Comic Convention wearing a gold bikini, coupled with a gun, holster, short jacket and obligatory goggles. Since then she’s had a lot of flak about whether the outfit was steampunk or not.

The main issue stemmed around the fact that a bikini wasn’t befitting of the time that she was trying to recreate. After all, it wasn’t invented until the 1940’s. It’s put me into a quandary as to who’s side I fall on. You see in principle I agree with the nay-sayers that a bikini wasn’t in use during the time period that we take our inspiration from. My biggest gripe is the material used. If the bikini had been made from lace or cotton, it maybe wouldn’t have as much of a negative impact.

One of the leading issues I have with the people who have been negative about it is that when Miss Wilder posted a picture on her Facebook page, she pointed out that she wanted to prove that she could steampunk even the most ridiculous of things. So was it intended as a tongue in cheek approach to the sub-culture? Possibly. If it was, then the pessimists look rather silly now.

To me, questioning someone’s outfit questions their interest in steampunk. Miss Wilder was essentially accused of not being a steampunk. Look through her Facebook page and she talks about steampunk all the time. She has albums dedicated to steampunk, alt and cosplay and her Model Mayhem account is littered with steampunk images. If you want more proof that she is a steampunk, she constantly gets fitted out by Brute Force Studios. Anyone that Brute Force give a nod to are good sports in my Journal.

Is this a reasonable comparison?
Lady Clankington, Kato and Amy Wilder

In the comments section of her recent post, she posted a triptych featuring Lady Clankington, Kato and herself. She labelled them “Steampunk Royalty”, “Steampunk Supermodel” and “offensive, not steampunk” and I can see her argument. All three are ladies that use their bodies to promote themselves but also enjoy steampunk. However, as a photographer, I can see striking contrasts (no pun intended). You see, in the pictures Lady Clankington wears lace undergarments, Kato is in vintage styled lingerie accessorised with pearls and a cameo while Miss Wilder is in a shiny gold bikini. Lady Clankington and Kato are in subtle (albeit saucy) poses, while Miss Wilder looks over her shoulder in a poorly executed 1990’s glamour pose that serves nothing but the lurid minds of people not appreciating her for her cosplay efforts.

Now let’s take a look at the wider issues. Steampunk is all encompassing. We’re a jolly lot that welcome anyone into the culture and we’re proud to say that – unlike Victorian re-enactment – we can express ourselves as we wish. I’ve known people wear swimming goggles on their hats. So for anyone calling themselves a steampunk to approach someone else and berate them because they don’t fit in with a preconceived ideal is just not cricket. But then, my mind wanders to the rest of the outfit. There’s no denying that Miss Wilder is a steampunk. Saying that, the outfit she wore at SDCC – in my opinion – would be better designated as cyberpunk. To me, the bikini with the blaster rifle and her friends clad in latex suggests more a dystopian technological future where the world was suddenly thrust into a global war and everyone had to grab a gun and fight regardless of what they’re wearing.

My biggest concern about the whole thing is who these people thought they were that they can approach someone and say they aren’t steampunk. Just because she isn’t wearing what they think she should be wearing. Is that the ideal of steampunk? As steampunk becomes more fashionable and more people are introduced to it, we will see more of this, I dare say. Younger steampunks will start to evolve the culture and make it different to how it is now. Older steampunks may not like that and dig their heels in. There’s always a possibility that it will make steampunk unpleasant. Should steampunk change? Over on steamychums, another writer discussing this very story suggests that steampunk is an art form and as art it should be left to naturally evolve. Yet back in January, I posted an article about the rise in popularity of steampunk. It’s a buzz word. We’re in danger of steampunk being evolved by people who aren’t really steampunks because they’re “putting their own twist on it”. If they’re not steampunks I don’t want their twist on it and from that point of view I can see where the remarks came from.

But Amy Wilder IS a steampunk and should be met with the same courtesy that we extend to everyone inside AND outside our culture.

5 thoughts on “Steampunk model gets trouble for not being steampunk enough

  1. Whaaa? I have never seen this article! Wow, I’m kinda floored and flustered right now that someone though I was important enough to write about! =•__•=

    The “Steamkini” was indeed a joke meant to poke a bit of fun, but thank you for not being to terribly hard on me, and for saying nice things about me! Hopefully we might meet at a con someday!

    1. Hello, Amy. Thanks for the comment. I’ve tried to be neutral and honest throughout the article. You are most certainly worth talking about being an important figure in the culture.
      I felt the pose and actual photograph did you no favours with the people accusing you and that was my only real gripe. I felt it was terrible what people were saying, and while deep down I could kind of see their point I felt they were being unnecessarily harsh on you.
      I really so hope we can meet one day, you seem delightful with a marvellous sense of humour (I’m referring to your recent splendid photograph where you made fun at the ordeal by showing an ankle).

      Maybe an interview could be in store in the future.
      Thanks once again.

  2. I know Amy personally and she does amazing steampunk! Like the rest of us she experiments from time to time. Experimentation is part of steampunk as well. I say bravo to her and keep up the amazing work!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s